Question

News:Pubmed Commons : A System That Enables Researchers To Share Their Opinions About Scientific Publications

8

Entering edit mode

11.1 years ago

Pierre Lindenbaum 164k

via Pedro Beltrao:

The new Pubmed commenting system http://t.co/ZNmZAL8JYY @PubMedCommons
— Pedro Beltrao (@pedrobeltrao) October 22, 2013

\tweet 392668221993529345

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmedcommons/

PubMed Commons is a system that enables researchers to share their opinions about scientific publications. Researchers can comment on any publication indexed by PubMed, and read the comments of others. PubMed Commons is a forum for open and constructive criticism and discussion of scientific issues. It will thrive with high quality interchange from the scientific community. PubMed Commons is currently in a closed pilot testing phase, which means that only invited participants can add and view comments in PubMed.

enter image description here

Update:

And there is a new field for Entrez: via

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/?term=has_user_comments[sb]

ncbi pubmed • 6.5k views

ADD COMMENT • link updated 21 months ago by Ram 44k • written 11.1 years ago by Pierre Lindenbaum 164k

Ram · Answer 1 · 2013-10-23

5

Entering edit mode

11.1 years ago

Pierre Lindenbaum 164k

Here is my first comment in PubmedCommons for my article \pmid 9682060: "My code has moved to github"

enter image description here

ADD COMMENT • link updated 21 months ago by Ram 44k • written 11.1 years ago by Pierre Lindenbaum 164k

Ram · Answer 2 · 2013-10-22

4

Entering edit mode

11.1 years ago

Mary 11k

You should also see the discussion at Retraction Watch about this:

http://retractionwatch.wordpress.com/2013/10/22/pubmed-now-allows-comments-on-abstracts-but-only-by-a-select-few/

EDIT (after trying it out): I commented on the Biostar paper to kick the tires. I wondered what would happen if you invited an author--I thought that might be interesting to try and potentially useful (also a spam risk). But you have to know the author's email apparently.

Invite an author form

ADD COMMENT • link updated 21 months ago by Ram 44k • written 11.1 years ago by Mary 11k

2

Entering edit mode

I'm a little surprised that Retraction Watch are essentially calling for an anything-goes comment policy. PubMed is not YouTube.

ADD REPLY • link 11.1 years ago by Neilfws 49k

2

Entering edit mode

People have found this post helpful: Joining PubMed Commons: A Step-by-step Guide. If you want an invite and have a PubMed article I'm happy to try to give you an invite. Need one of your Pubmed IDs + the email for your MyNCBI account and I will do that invite as shown in the graphic here. That seemed to work for someone I invited.

ADD REPLY • link 11.1 years ago by Mary 11k

score 2 · Answer 3 · 2013-10-24

2

Entering edit mode

11.1 years ago

Damian Kao 16k

Are they importing comments from other sources? The comments on the DESeq paper dates from June: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20979621/

ADD COMMENT • link 11.1 years ago by Damian Kao 16k

score 1 · Answer 4 · 2013-10-22

1

Entering edit mode

11.1 years ago

Istvan Albert 101k

The PLoS journals also have this option, though so far seems to get very little use.