Cytoscape Or Gephi?

Question

[lkmklsmn]

I am vaguely familiar with the network visualization softwares cytoscape and gephi.

Before I go more into depth with one of them I would like to hear about pros and cons of each.

Any comments?

Answer 1

[Istvan Albert]

Cytoscape has biology awareness, recognizes formats such as SMBL and knows about gene ontology formats and data. The apps developed for Cytoscale are mostly systems biology oriented.

Gephi is a more generic network visualizer that is not targeting any specific use case.

[Superbest]

This is exactly my impression. One thing to add: Gephi is a smaller, simpler, perhaps less "mature" project than Cytoscape. Therefore, if you just want a quick and dirty network visualizer to get a feel for the basics, Gephi may be a good place to start, because it is less complicated and not as confusing the first time you use it. For actual, real world research involving biological networks, Cytoscape will probably be necessary to use, however.

Answer 2

[keiono]

Disclosure: I'm a core developer of Cytoscape

Cytoscape is a de-facto standard in life science research, mainly because of large user community and its Apps. Of course, Gephi has some advantages over Cytoscape, such as nice presets and built-in statistical analysis module and we, Cytoscape core team, is learning from them. If you have feature request which is available in Gephi but not in Cytoscape, please let us know :)

Answer 3

[dcolinmorgan]

I would highly recommend Cytoscape 3 - it has a much more polished, refined UI, and the new "app store" continues this trend by facilitating simple plugin installation - however, not all plugins are supported by version 3; version 2.8 is still very usable and supports the majority of plugins out there. However, many large datasets I had trouble loading into version 3 were tackled by version 2.8 no problem, I suspect due to visualization improvement requirements.

I have only played around with gephi, and my impressions are exactly what Istvan noted - its intended use for a broader audience makes its use not as straightforward regarding biological data

Answer 4

[clementlevallois]

Disclosure: I am a member of the Gephi community support team.

I agree with what Istvan Albert and keiono have shared. Cytoscape has a much broader ecology of plugins for biological research, for example. One strength of Gephi is that it handles well the visualization of very large, dynamic networks.

Both software keep evolving, so it is worth re-checking their features periodically. If you have any question or feature request for Gephi please use the forum of Gephi, post on the Facebook group or give a shout to @gephi on Twitter.

Answer 5

[Woa]

Check some cytoscape generated images: http://cytoscape-publications.tumblr.com/